For Hanukkah, Catholic News Site Sent Jews an Image of Destruction and Looting December 5, 2018

For Hanukkah, Catholic News Site Sent Jews an Image of Destruction and Looting

And now, a war on Hanukkah?

It briefly seemed that way when, the other day, Catholic News Service (CNS) tweeted a holiday greeting to Jews around the world, featuring a photo of an ancient relief that shows a gathering of men hoisting a menorah. It was a nice gesture of interfaith goodwill — except that the image depicts first-century Roman soldiers carrying off Jewish loot after laying waste to Jerusalem in the Great Revolt, also known as the First Jewish-Roman War.

The relief is part of a still-standing famous victory arch in Rome called the Arch of Titus.

So … was the Hanukkah greeting by the Catholic outfit a nose-thumbing display of glee and Schadenfreude, or a genuine message marred by the well-wishers’ art-historic cluelessness?

CNS swears that it’s the latter. It promptly deleted the tweet when critics pointed out how bizarre it was and issued an apology.

“The person who posted the tweet now fully understands the implications of the picture,”

CNS assured everyone. And that appears to be the end of the accidental hostilities.

Should Jewish retaliation become necessary after all, I helpfully mocked up this holiday card.

(Top image via @joshtpm. Middle image via Wikipedia)

"If you're religious or sort of religious you can get away with anything ..."

200 Women Accuse Celebrity “Spiritual Healer” ..."
"Cardinal Pell wasn't sidelined for child sexual abuse. He was sidelined for lack of discretion."

Cardinal Booted from Pope’s Inner Circle ..."
"I made it clear that I am not a qualified apologist. Please direct your obvious ..."

Here’s Why the Fertility Clinic “Dilemma” ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment