Neil deGrasse Tyson, Without Saying “Atheist,” Told CBS Why He Doesn’t Believe in a Creator May 1, 2017

Neil deGrasse Tyson, Without Saying “Atheist,” Told CBS Why He Doesn’t Believe in a Creator

CBS’ Sunday Morning aired a wonderful segment about Neil deGrasse Tyson yesterday, but they left a segment about God on the cutting room floor. Thankfully, they put it up on their website.

Tyson never used the word “atheist” in his response — no surprise there — but his explanation of why he didn’t accept the traditional idea of a Higher Power was excellent.


The more I look at the universe, the less convinced I am that there is something benevolent going on…

… I look at disasters that afflict Earth, and life on Earth: volcanoes, hurricanes, tornadoes, earthquakes, disease, pestilence, congenital birth defects. You look at this list of ways that life is made miserable on Earth by natural causes, and I just ask, “How do you deal with that?”

So philosophers rose up and said, “If there is a God, God is either not all powerful or not all good.”

I have no problems if, as we probe the origins of things, we bump into the Bearded Man. If that shows up, we good to go! Okay? Not a problem.

There’s just no evidence of it.

And this is why religions are called “faiths” collectively. Because you believe something in the absence of evidence. That’s what it is! That’s why it’s called “faith”! Otherwise we would call all religions “evidence,” but we don’t, for exactly that reason.

Comedian Stephen Fry once gave a similar answer that I thought was more to the point. He explained why he didn’t just not believe in God, but why he wouldn’t want to believe in God.

Still, if Tyson’s response helps nudge people away from faith, more power to him.

(Thanks to Larry for the link)

"yep. when it's coming out of both ends, always, and i mean always, sit on ..."

Pastor: Bernie Sanders Is “Completely Illiterate” ..."
"You have to understand the right wing mindset...only the most fervent fundie is a "real" ..."

After Backlash, Berea (KY) City Council ..."
"I understand that it's not an option for all women but you don't think it ..."

Woman Says Priest Forced Her to ..."
"No, no, no. Trump's strong support for Israel gets the blame."

Televangelist: God Caused a Huge Oil Spill ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment