Just Because ISIS Recruits Aren’t Islamic Scholars Doesn’t Mean They Aren’t Swayed By Religion August 23, 2016

Just Because ISIS Recruits Aren’t Islamic Scholars Doesn’t Mean They Aren’t Swayed By Religion

A report from the Associated Press a couple of weeks ago claimed that the earliest ISIS recruits actually knew very little about Islam.


It’s not that they understood the faith and that’s why they went to join the terrorists. It’s that they knew so little, they were more susceptible to pressure from those claiming to speak on behalf of Islam.

An AP analysis of thousands of leaked Islamic State documents reveals most of its recruits from its earliest days came with only the most basic knowledge of Islam

According to the documents, which were acquired by the Syrian opposition site Zaman al-Wasl and shared with the AP, 70 percent of recruits were listed as having just “basic” knowledge of Shariah — the lowest possible choice. Around 24 percent were categorized as having an “intermediate” knowledge, with just 5 percent considered advanced students of Islam. Five recruits were listed as having memorized the Quran.

Another way to interpret those results, however, is to say that religion had little or nothing to do with their recruitment. As one former CIA officer put it, “Religion is an afterthought” for those members.

But Ron Lindsay of the Center For Inquiry takes issue with that kind of argument. It’s foolish to claim religion isn’t a potent ingredient in the mix, he argues, even if recruits didn’t necessarily understand it.

That argument is seriously flawed. It rests on a faulty premise, namely that one needs to be thoroughly familiar with a religion’s doctrines to be motivated by that religion to engage in violence or embrace extreme positions on moral, legal, and political issues. There is no support for this premise.

… There are many factors other than religious belief that can play a role in causing someone to support terrorism, including social isolation, a sense of disenfranchisement, and so forth. But it’s a mistake to exclude religious belief as a factor. It doesn’t matter whether the person knows the details of The One True Belief as long as they are committed to The One True Belief. Far too often in human history, those committed to The One True Belief have viewed individual human lives as unimportant when compared to the greater glory of God.

In other words, even if they didn’t fully understand Islam, they were still motivated by a desire to please Allah. And that’s why it’s important not to discount religion’s role in what ISIS does.

There’s no point in arguing what “True Islam” is, because different believers will say different things, but there’s no denying how many terrorists throughout history have killed innocent people because they felt they were defending their God’s honor.

That’s why we must continue to speak out about the harm in irrational religious beliefs. Even if belief in God motivates some people to be good, it’s so easy to manipulate people who are trying to please a fictional being. We’re better off convincing people to accept reason and evidence over faith and emotion.

(Image via Shutterstock)

"The way republican politics are going these days, that means the winner is worse than ..."

It’s Moving Day for the Friendly ..."
"It would have been more convincing if he used then rather than than."

It’s Moving Day for the Friendly ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
error: Content is protected !!