When People Change Religions, Logic and Reason Aren’t Always in the Picture February 17, 2016

When People Change Religions, Logic and Reason Aren’t Always in the Picture

In a brief but fascinating interview with Staks Rosch at Publishers Weekly, author Susan Jacoby talks about her new book Strange Gods: A Secular History of Conversion:


She explained why people change their faith — and wouldn’t you know it, logic and reason aren’t always the primary reasons.

People generally think about conversion only in terms of a spiritual journey, when in fact, there are a lot of secular factors involved. Sometimes it is simply that the political winds have shifted. Another factor is discrimination against minorities. That was a huge factor in my father’s family because of anti-Semitism — people perceived being a Jew as a disadvantage. Also, the history of conversion is rife with people who adopt religion or another religion because they think it will help them overcome a personal failing or some compulsion like alcoholism, and in many cases, it does. But the most powerful secular factor promoting religious conversion is religious inter-marriage.

That never made sense to me. I get the practical reasons for it (to appease your partner’s parents, for example), but I never understood how some people could genuinely just drop whatever their current beliefs are and magically adopt a new religion.

If they’re willing to change their faith at the drop of a hat, it suggests that even they don’t take religion very seriously.

"I must watch it again, I didn't realise the photography was that detailed..."

Anti-LGBTQ Official Drops AL Senate Bid After Mistress ..."
"Triggered? I've been launched."

Jerry Falwell, Jr. is Urging People ..."
"How much "ground" is there in the "spiritual realm"?Surely, it's infinite.Which means that no matter ..."

GOP Conspiracist Lawmaker: Christians Are “Taking ..."
"Hmm... sounds like you've been... TRIGGERED!These conservatives better stop, or we'll file a petition!"

Jerry Falwell, Jr. is Urging People ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment