Last night, Stephen Colbert tackled American Atheists’ lawsuit against the National September 11 Memorial and Museum and its exhibit featuring a Christian cross.
Here’s why I didn’t like the segment — and it has nothing to do with the fact that atheists were the targets of the jokes. (And, yes, I’m aware I’m overanalyzing a comedy segment that admittedly made me laugh.)
The basic argument is that this cross provides emotional relief for Christians and that alone should be reason to allow it. But as soon as you open that door, it means saying yes to roadside crosses on public property and prayer before public high school football games and anywhere else Christians may want to push their faith.
If you want to complain about what American Atheists is doing, then tackle their argument that the cross amounts to an endorsement of religion and a violation of the First Amendment. How it makes Christians feel is irrelevant.