Why Duck Dynasty Patriarch Phil Robertson’s Joke About Atheists Makes No Sense September 6, 2013

Why Duck Dynasty Patriarch Phil Robertson’s Joke About Atheists Makes No Sense

Phil Robertson, the patriarch of the family featured on the reality show “Duck Dynasty,” was giving a sermon at White’s Ferry Road church in Louisiana last weekend and make a crack at atheists that really makes no sense whatsoever when you give it more than a second of thought:

here comes ten dudes, coming towards you. And they’re all carrying something in their hand. There’s your wife [and your] kids. And you’re thinking, “Oh my goodness, it’s three in the morning. Here comes ten dudes coming toward me. And I’m in a major metropolitan area of the United States of America.” And as they get close enough, and come into the light a little bit, they’re all carrying Bibles. [Late night] Bible study.

Even if you’re an atheist, tell the truth: You would feel better about it. Right? I’m just sayin’.

So I’ve looked at both groups. I’ve looked at the Bible Thumpers, and the ones that carry other things in their hands besides Bibles. Oh, I’ll take the Bible Thumpers every day of the week.

Since the churchgoers in the video all seem to agree that even atheists would be relieved to see the strangers carrying Bibles, and that Christians with Bibles are automatically good people you wouldn’t mind running into late at night, let’s pop their bubble. It’s not that hard to do.

If I were walking down a city street at night and a bunch of dudes were coming toward me… and I found out they were carrying books — any books — I would be relieved.

It has nothing to do with the Bible. They could be carrying the Koran, or Dr. Seuss books, or the Fifty Shades of Grey trilogy, or even a Kindle — at 3:00a, I’m not about to discriminate.

Any of those would be better than whatever I *think* they have in their hands.

And you know what? If Phil Robertson were walking down the street at night, and a group of guys walked towards him, and they were all carrying The God Delusion, he’d be pretty damn relieved, too.

Incidentally, in God Is Not Great, Christopher Hitchens brings up a very similar scenario. He recalls a panel where he was asked to imagine himself in a strange city late one night:

Now — would I feel safer, or less safe, if I was to learn that they were just coming from a prayer meeting?… I was able to answer it as if it were not hypothetical. “Just to stay within the letter ‘B,’ I have actually had that experience in Belfast, Beirut, Bombay, Belgrade, Bethlehem, and Baghdad. In each case I can say absolutely, and can give my reasons, why I would feel immediately threatened if I thought that the group of men approaching me in the dusk were coming from a religious observance.”

(via The Blaze)

"My 3 teenagers' heathen friends were all getting tattoos and they were thinking about it. ..."

Baptisms at Many Evangelical Churches Are ..."
"His family blames people spreading the evils of Satan for his death.They fail to mention ..."

Marcus Lamb, Whose Christian TV Network ..."
"You wrote, a few comments ago:"Sex is a trait that determines an individual's reproductive function, ..."

Oregon School Board Reverses Decision to ..."
"And yelling ogodogodogod a lot!"

How Sex Workers Operate in the ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • timedonkey

    Nothing is more dangerous than a group of Bible trumpeters coming after your soul, they will stop at nothing because they think they are right and everyone else is not just wrong, but a tool of another imaginary character, Satan, yes Satan. Think crusades, Salem witch burnings, Slavery was justified because it was in the Bible and the excuse the Royals and Popes gave was that they were ‘saving’ the heathen by enslaving them and giving them the Bible. You see these old guys that do not smoke marijuana are often blinded by their beliefs.

  • JimT

    It is a shame that people (even religious people) can’t understand what he (Phil) is saying, because Jesus said: ” Except a man be born again he cannot even see the Kingdom of Heaven”. (And He was talking to a religious person at the time.)That means sinners sin and think there is nothing wrong. But I am here to say: SINNER YOU DONT HAVE TO SIN ANYMORE. Once you are free from sin you step out of the darkness into the light and you realize that God is real, God is love (more than you know or can understand). you will still sin but not live in Sin! Like a snake shedding his skin.

  • madguitarist

    Well played, sir. I do see where he’s coming from with what he said, but I do agree that I would be just as relieved if it were any other book in their hands…maybe college textbooks, because they were doing a late night group cram for a test. This is a much more probable “book carrying in the middle of the night” scenario…just sayin’ 😉

  • james


    put that in your smart ass pipe and smoke it!

  • Русская мафия уборщик

    stop liking yourself, stop liking yourself… 😉

  • Still Christian

    WOW, just WoW…Someone stands for something that is good and has a message that turned his life from the sewer to prosperity and all everyone can do is criticize him. Looks like Phil Robertson is now a victim of hate crimes and discrimination.

  • Mike

    Makes perfect sense to me. If a gang of people approached me at 3AM, I wouldn’t wonder if they were Jehovah’s Witnesses on an early morning jaunt. I’d wonder if they were going to gun me down. Anyone who doesn’t get what Robertson was saying is probably someone who’s never been out late in a busy city.

    Atheists would rather see a group of people with Bibles than a group of people with Uzis and Glocks heading their way…as would anyone, I imagine.

  • Anthony J Peasley

    Because Neo-nazis, Aryan nation, skineads etc. NEVER would beat the shit out of someone for their perceived sexuality while holding bibles…

  • Albino alligator

    If they all have in-bred beards who cares what they carry???? Shoot the wooly boogers.

error: Content is protected !!