Chicago Atheists and Their Doppelgangers September 13, 2007

Chicago Atheists and Their Doppelgangers

A couple months ago, another person named Hemant Mehta was in the news because he was suing Snapple.

Apparently, I’m not the only atheist from Chicago with a clone.


Rob Sherman (the atheist) is in the news because Rob Sherman (not the atheist) published a fake interview with Barack Obama in a French magazine. The non-atheist Sherman also faked interviews with other people:

Reports surfaced this week that a former ABC News consultant, Alexis Debat, hired a suburban Chicago freelance reporter — named Rob Sherman — to interview Obama. French magazine Rue 89 claims the interview was made up. Other politicians, including United Nations Secretary General Kofi Annan, former President Bill Clinton and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, then added their names to the chorus alleging Debat faked their interviews, too.

“I’m doing everything to say I am the prominent Rob Sherman in Chicago, and I’ve never been involved with this guy,” [atheist Sherman] said.

Gotta love his demeanor. It doesn’t stop there, either:

Washington Post Media Critic Howard Kurtz also has been working on stories about Debat’s credibility. He said he, too, had not been able to locate the Rob Sherman with whom the French writer supposedly dealt. But he did learn a quite a bit as a result of his own interviews.

“It’s not the famous atheist,” he said, a fact Debat confirmed.

“Debat told us it was not that Rob Sherman,” Kurtz said.

After Sherman wrote an e mail to Debat asking for an explanation, he, too, received as response exonerating him.

Not that it’s stopping journalists from placing phone calls to the Buffalo Grove man who rarely shies away from the spotlight. And he answers every call.

“I’ve got a national reputation to maintain,” Sherman said.

Sherman (the atheist) is the man responsible for informing us of the George Bush, Sr. quotation:

No, I don’t know that atheists should be considered as citizens, nor should they be considered patriots. This is one nation under God.

However, that remark was not recorded and no other reporter admits to having heard Bush say that. It’s not a quotation we should be repeating as fact.

Sherman once asked me if I’d be willing to join him in a lawsuit to sue the city of Chicago. There was a streetlight that was pointed directly at a church that I lived near. I think the gist of the argument was that the taxpayer-funded streetlight was being used to illuminate the historic church instead of lighting up the street in front of it and that was a violation of the law.

I declined to join him.

Also, and very unfortunately, his son Ricky was wrongly fired from a high school teaching job because of his infamous father. Sherman (the son) did get a job at another school district, though.

[tags]atheist, atheism, Chicago, Ricky Sherman, Eric Zorn, Daily Herald[/tags]

"The way republican politics are going these days, that means the winner is worse than ..."

It’s Moving Day for the Friendly ..."
"It would have been more convincing if he used then rather than than."

It’s Moving Day for the Friendly ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Bad

    However, that remark was not recorded and no other reporter admits to having heard Bush say that. It’s not a quotation we should be repeating as fact.

    In Sherman’s favor though:

    1) he succeeded in getting a FOIA document release that proved the key aspects of his story
    2) Bush Sr.’s people have never denied that he said it, and in fact answered questions about in implying that it did in fact take place

  • Richard Wade

    Woe unto anyone who shares their name with someone who becomes infamous, especially in this age of fast-as-light misinformation. I’m sure more than one guy named Al Kayda have suffered a severe drop in business, and if any of those born under the name Ben Lodin haven’t committed suicide, they probably got their names changed to Pat Triot or something.

  • Wow, it sure makes me glad there are is not one other person in the entire United States with the same name as me. (Yes, I’m quite sure. I know all 9 of the people with the same last name. We’re all closely related.)

error: Content is protected !!