Texas Judge Says Bible Verse Poster at Public School is Legal, But Needs a (Pointless) Disclaimer

Earlier this month, Dedra Shannon, a staffer at Patterson Middle School in Killeen, Texas, put up a poster outside her classroom featuring a scene from A Charlie Brown Christmas. It was Linus reciting a Bible verse: “For unto you is born this day in the city of David a savior which is Christ the Lord. That’s what Christmas is all about, Charlie Brown.”

ChristmasCharlieBrownJesus

The school’s principal asked her to take it down because it could be seen as a promotion of religion, to which Shannon replied, “It is a slap in the face of Christianity.” No it wasn’t, and that response was exactly the point. This was always about promoting Christianity!

But then Fox News’ Todd Starnes got involved. And then Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton got involved. And now a judge has gotten involved, calling for the display to be restored.

After an hour-long hearing, Judge Jack Jones ruled that the door display… should be put back up with an added line: “Ms. Shannon’s Christmas message.”

“Religious discrimination towards Christians has become a holiday tradition of sorts among certain groups,” Paxton said in a statement after the judge’s decision. “I am glad to see that the court broke through the left’s rhetorical fog and recognized that a commitment to diversity means protecting everyone’s individual religious expression.”

That has to be the strangest possible way to resolve this matter.

What rule of law are we following now? Are teachers allowed to post Bible verses in their classrooms as long as there’s a disclaimer that it’s just their personal beliefs? Does that rule also apply to Muslim staffers? Atheists? Satanists? Can science teachers post signs saying, “Axial tilt is the reason for the season… this sign brought to you by reality”?

If there isn’t a challenge to this ruling, then what’s stopping teachers from posting Bible verses all around the District? Because give it a few weeks and you’ll see them everywhere.

It’s not “persecution” to say public school employees shouldn’t be proselytizing while on the clock. Just because the verse appeared in a Christmas-themed play doesn’t make it okay, either.

(Thanks to Scott for the link)


"Not at all! I had some time waiting for the dentist yesterday, but need to ..."

“Pro-Life Agnostic” Austin Petersen Loses Missouri ..."
"The only thing I’m prepared to credit him with is hubris. Quite an astonishing display ..."

“Pro-Life Agnostic” Austin Petersen Loses Missouri ..."
"The comment above contained a mention of Cynthia when I wrote it, but Disqus disappeared ..."

“Pro-Life Agnostic” Austin Petersen Loses Missouri ..."
"If he pushes too hard, he can cause churches around the globe to leave the ..."

Pope Francis Urges Catholics to Pray ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment